Who is a Muslim, and what are the key sources of Muslim law?

Introduction

Muslim law, as applied in India, encompasses a unique set of principles derived from Islamic religious sources. The foundation of this law is embedded in the teachings of the Quran and the traditions of Prophet Muhammad, known as the Hadith. Over time, the interpretation and adaptation of these sources have been influenced by various schools of Islamic jurisprudence, which are divided mainly between Sunni and Shia traditions. Indian Muslim law, though not entirely codified, has been partially regulated through legislative acts such as the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937, and the Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act, 1939, which provide statutory recognition to certain aspects of Muslim personal law. Muslim law in India is a personal law and applies only to individuals who identify as Muslims, specifically in matters like marriage, divorce, and inheritance. In interpreting these laws, Indian courts seek to balance traditional tenets with considerations of equity, justice, and the evolving societal context.

Who is a Muslim?

A Muslim is defined as an individual who practices Islam, a faith that is characterized by belief in one God, Allah, and recognition of Prophet Muhammad as Allah’s messenger. For the purpose of applying Muslim law, Muslims are categorized either by birth or by religious conversion. Those born to Muslim parents are considered Muslims, though distinctions arise when only one parent is Muslim, depending on the child’s upbringing. Muslim law also extends to converts, who adopt the faith either through professed belief or formal ceremonies. Within this framework, Muslim law in India also recognizes specific groups, such as the Khojas and Bohras, as adherents to Islamic law.

Notably, religious freedom enshrined in the Indian Constitution allows any individual to convert to Islam, with conversion formally recognized under Article 25[1]. This has implications in personal matters, as courts have ruled against conversions motivated solely by the desire to sidestep legal constraints in other religions, notably in cases of bigamy under Hindu law.

Tenets of Islam

The Five Pillars of Islam are foundational practices that guide the lives of Muslims. Each pillar emphasizes a distinct aspect of faith and devotion, helping Muslims align their lives with spiritual and ethical principles.

1. Declaration of Faith (Shahada): The Shahada is the central expression of Islamic belief, affirming the oneness of God and the prophethood of Muhammad. This simple yet profound statement, "There is no god but Allah, and Muhammad is His Messenger," signifies a Muslim’s complete submission to God. Reciting this phrase with sincerity is the fundamental act by which one enters the faith of Islam.
2. Prayer (Salat): Prayer is a vital practice in Islam, performed five times daily at specific times: dawn, noon, mid-afternoon, sunset, and evening. Each prayer involves recitations from the Qur’an and movements that reflect humility and devotion. Muslims pray facing the holy city of Mecca, often using a prayer mat, which helps create a focused and sacred space for worship. Congregational prayer, especially on Fridays, brings the community together, with an imam leading the prayer and delivering a sermon on a relevant topic.
3. Charity (Zakat): Zakat is the practice of giving a set portion of one’s wealth to those in need, emphasizing social responsibility and compassion. By contributing a share of their income, Muslims support the welfare of their community, help alleviate poverty, and foster a sense of shared responsibility. Acts of charity extend beyond monetary contributions and can also include providing resources like hospitals, schools, and public services.
4. Fasting (Sawm): During the month of Ramadan, Muslims fast from dawn until sunset, refraining from food, drink, and other physical needs. This fast is a time of self-reflection, gratitude, and spiritual renewal, reminding Muslims of their blessings and the importance of empathy toward those less fortunate. Fasting also honors the month in which the Qur’an was first revealed to the Prophet Muhammad, making it a period of deep personal and communal significance.
5. Pilgrimage (Hajj): Hajj is a pilgrimage to the holy city of Mecca that every Muslim is expected to undertake at least once in their lifetime, provided they are physically and financially able. The journey includes visiting the Ka’ba, a revered structure at the heart of Mecca, and performing rituals that honor the faith’s history and unity. Pilgrims gather from around the world, transcending race, culture, and status, symbolizing the unity and equality of all Muslims under God.

Sources of Muslim Law: Primary and Secondary Sources in India

Muslim law, rooted in a combination of divine revelation and juristic interpretation, is primarily derived from the following foundational sources, which together form the core legal framework within Islamic jurisprudence. In India, these sources are divided into primary and secondary categories.

Primary Sources of Muslim Law

1. The Quran: The Quran, derived from the Arabic word Qurra meaning "to read," is the fundamental source of Islamic law and is revered as the direct word of God revealed to Prophet Mohammed. Muslims believe that these revelations were communicated through the angel Gabriel, spanning over 23 years. This holy book is comprehensive in its guidance, covering both religious doctrine and principles governing human behavior, thereby serving as the bedrock of all Islamic teachings and laws. The Quran comprises 114 chapters (suras) and 6,666 verses (ayats) and covers a vast array of subjects, including laws on marriage, inheritance, and property rights. Its immutable nature underscores its final authority on all matters of Muslim law.
2. Sunna (Traditions or Hadis): Sunna, which translates to "the trodden path," represents the second primary source of Muslim law. This body of traditions includes the actions, statements, and silent approvals of Prophet Mohammed, collectively known as Hadis. Muslims believe that the Prophet's teachings, even when not explicitly outlined in the Quran, provide divine guidance. Traditions, or Sunna, offer insights into the Prophet’s conduct through Sunnat-ul-Qual (his words), Sunnat-ul-Fail (his actions), and Sunnat-ul-Tahrir (his silent approvals). Thus, Sunna supplements the Quran by guiding matters not expressly covered within it and solidifying Islamic jurisprudence.
3. Ijma (Consensus of Jurists): Following the Prophet's demise, the consensus of learned Islamic jurists, or Ijma, emerged as a source of Muslim law. This collective agreement, particularly from Mujtahids (jurists with profound knowledge of Islam), provided interpretations and expansions on issues where the Quran or Sunna was silent. Ijma holds substantial authority in Muslim law, nearly equating to the Quran and Sunna. It can take various forms, including Ijma of Companions (the companions of the Prophet), Ijma of Jurists (agreement among scholars), and Ijma of the People (accepted majority opinion), though the latter is given less weight in legal contexts.
4. Qiyas (Analogical Reasoning): Qiyas, or analogical reasoning, serves as the fourth primary source of Islamic law. In cases where the Quran, Sunna, or Ijma lack explicit guidance, jurists apply Qiyas to deduce rulings by drawing analogies with existing laws. This method, emphasizing logical interpretation without creating new laws, expands the reach of Islamic law to address contemporary issues. Although Qiyas holds lesser authority than the other primary sources, it remains an important interpretive tool in Islamic jurisprudence, particularly embraced within the Hanafi school of thought.

Secondary Sources of Muslim Law

1. Legislation: Despite the largely uncodified nature of Muslim law in India, Parliament has enacted specific statutes to regulate certain aspects. Key legislations include the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937, governing marriage, succession, and inheritance, and the Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act, 1939, addressing divorce matters. Such legislative interventions provide a statutory framework to supplement the primary Islamic sources.
2. Judicial Decisions (Precedent): Indian courts frequently interpret Muslim law, drawing on primary sources and existing legislation to resolve legal ambiguities. Through the principle of stare decisis, judicial decisions establish precedents that lower courts must follow, thereby shaping Muslim law through case law. These precedents have clarified various legal questions and play a crucial role in applying Islamic principles within the Indian legal context.
3. Customs: Long-standing customs, or urf, which have been observed over time and accepted by the community, can attain the force of law under certain conditions. For a custom to be recognized in Muslim law, it must be reasonable, universally applicable, consistent with Islamic principles, and possess temporal relevance. Customs continue to play a supplementary role, shaping the behavioral and societal norms within Muslim communities in India.

Conclusion

Muslim law in India derives from a structured hierarchy of sources. The primary sources, the Quran, Sunna, Ijma, and Qiyas constitute the divine and foundational basis for Islamic jurisprudence. Secondary sources, legislation, judicial decisions, and customs support the primary sources, providing flexibility and adapting Islamic law to India's legal and societal environment. Together, these sources ensure that Muslim law remains both rooted in tradition and responsive to contemporary legal needs.

[1] The Indian Constitution, art. 25.

#InheritanceandDivorceinMuslimLaw #IslamicSources #indiancourts #IslamicLaw #JudicialPrecedent #legislation #urf #customs #Qiyas #AnalogicalReasoning #shahada #salat #FivePillarsofIslam #zakat #swam #hajj #Ijma #ConsensusofJurists #ConversiontoIslam #muslimidentity #ReligiousFreedom #personallaw #article25 #indianconstitution #shia #sunni #IslamicJurisprudence #quran #shariat #DissolutionofMuslimMarriagesAct,1939 #MuslimPersonalLaw(Shariat)ApplicationAct,1937 #hadith #muslimlaw #india